Features

The Beatles: Revolver album tracks ranked best to worst

revolver_50

It’s 50 years old TODAY and I think it’s fair to say that over recent years and decades The Beatles‘ seventh studio album Revolver, with its monochrome Klaus Voorman designed cover, has overtaken the colourful and psychedelic Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band as the critics’, and perhaps the fans’, favourite Beatles album.

So let’s examine what is one of the best albums in the world and, for fun, SDE will go through the tracks on Revolver and rank them from best to worst…

1. I’m Only Sleeping 

My favourite song the album, has that weirdness that distinguishes Revolver from Rubber Soul. Brilliant lyric, backwards guitar, some nice bits of Paul vocal harmony (“keeping an eye on the world GOING BY MY WINDOW”), those spaces where the bass goes “bom, bom, bom, bom” and the eastern influenced outro. Perfect.

2. Eleanor Rigby

Paul at his very best. Great lyric, great drama and great pathos. Structurally this song is brilliant. The ‘chorus’ is “all the lonely people…” but then there’s the refrain of “ahh, look at all the lonely people” at 1.19 which has a completely different melody and Paul later uses as a counter-melody at around 1.50. George Martin’s superb string arrangement keeps the pace up and the momentum driving forward. “Father McKenzie” was going to be Father McCartney, but Paul considered that a little too close to home. If you want ‘more’ of Eleanor Rigby then try (a-hem) Eleanor Rigby/Eleanor’s Dream from Paul’s 1984 soundtrack Give My Regards to Broadstreet. It extends the track to nine minutes and George Martin is at the helm again. Interesting if nothing else.

3. Taxman

The first track on the album (not if you bought the cassette tape in the 1970s, that reordered the album and stared with Good Day Sunshine) and apparently the first Beatles lyric not concerned with that thing called lurrvve. For me this song, more than any other defines RevolverThat bass line, that guitar solo are both Paul, but the lyric is pithy George at his best. John said (rather grumpily) in an interview that he helped George a great deal with this track even though he wasn’t credited. At this stage I don’t think we’ll ever know the truth around that.

4. Here, There and Everywhere

Paul often cites this as his best, or one of his best, songs. Hard to argue with that. If anyone ever doubted his talent, the sheer craft and skill with melody and lyric is something to behold. Although I love the album version, I also rate the Anthology / Real Love CD single outtake/remix, which has a single tracked vocal and brings in the harmonies at the end.

5. Tomorrow Never Knows

This track still sounds unbelievable today, so I’d love to have been there when people first played this 50 years ago. A perfect album closer, and in terms of studio experimentation and the avant garde, surpassed anything Lennon did on Sgt. Pepper.

6. And Your Bird Can Sing

I must admit the ‘laughing’ outtake of And Your Bird Can Sing first heard at the end of one of The Beatles Anthology programmes in 1995 increased my love for this song. The – clearly high – fab four giggling away while trying to do vocal overdubs is infectious. I have no idea what John is singing about, but even if meaningless his lyrics were never not interesting.

7. For No One

Another classic in the vein of Eleanor Rigby. It’s the lyric that makes all the difference, mature, understated, moving. The french horn is perfect. John and George don’t play on this at all.

8. Doctor Robert

On the face of it a fairly lightweight number, but this song just sounds so damn good. The guitar and rhythm section is amazing and I defy anyone not to sing along to the great harmonies “he’s a MAN YOU MUST BELIEVE…”. Paul and John singing together is pure heaven, sometimes. Also, so many of John’s songs on the album had drug influenced lyrics, and I like the fact that his ‘social’ habits were informing his work!

9. She Said She Said

Bonus points straight off, for the way the title repeats “She Said”. I first listened to Revolver as a seven or eight year old child, casually playing my Dad’s mono original with wonderment. This song has some great hooks, especially the “and you’re making me feel like I’ve never been born line”. Great drumming from Ringo.

10. Love You To

Much better than Within You Without You from Pepper, it’s a testament to George’s Love You To that you almost forget about the Indian instrumentation as the spiritual lyrics and the melody pull you in.

11. Got to Get You into My Life

I’ve gone off this song over the years. It used to be a big favourite, and a great singalong, but these days I feel like it doesn’t really ‘fit’ on Revolver. This was issued as a single in 1976 to promote those Rock ‘n’ Roll albums, and was The Beatles’ last US top ten hit until Free As A Bird nearly 20 years later.

12. Yellow Submarine

Okay, so it’s a jokey children’s song written for Ringo, but as jokey children’s songs go, it’s a good ‘un! A Beatles classic and not the worst thing on the album (see below).

13. I Want To Tell You

Not bad I suppose, but the rather droney and moany I Want To Tell You doesn’t feel like much of a progression from some of George Harrison’s contributions to Rubber Soul, particularly If I Needed Someone, which I think is a much better song. The piano is quite annoying on this track, although the outro is satisfying.

14. Good Day Sunshine

The rather bassy piano accompaniment and the, frankly, boring lyric, combined with the ‘isn’t life great’ outlook make this McCartney song my least favourite track from Revolver.

Do you agree with this ranking? Leave a comment with your views!

You might also like…

103 responses to The Beatles: Revolver album tracks ranked best to worst

  1. fredpostman says:

    Please Paul no more lists;this is the reason i stopped buying ‘Q’ years ago [actually ‘Rubber Soul’ is better]

    • Mark Carroll says:

      I stopped buying “Q” because I got sick & tired of seeing U2 on the cover, not that I hate them, I’ve seen em 5 times but I’ve become bored with them….

    • Paul says:

      +1

      And really this ‘best to worst’ is just one person’s preferences

    • Craig Williams says:

      Good then that you get this blog for free then isn’t it?!

  2. Bill says:

    It’s The Beatles Revolver.

    It’s ranked brilliant to not quite so brilliant. Not best to worst.

  3. Justin Isbell says:

    I like lists and I’ll have a considered re-listen later, but straight away I think Dr Robert should be further down and Tomorrow Never Knows higher up. Could also have thrown in period B-sides to see where they rank. And personally I prefer Abbey Road or Magical Mystery Tour but Revolver is still a good’un :-)

  4. Craig Hedges says:

    50 years – thats almost half a century!

    I had the cassette for Christmas 1984 so I got to know that line up and still can’t get used to Taxman at the start of the album. I’ve read since that rearranging the tracks was a pointless exercise as it has little impact. (for those young readers who don’t understand in the 1970s when albums were issued on tape the record companies would change the order of the tracks to try and make both sides of the tape equal length so that side one would end when then last track finished so you could turn it straight over).
    I’d also pinched my moms copy of the Beach Boys 20 golden greats and was just listening to Wouldn’t it be nice and God only knows which looking back is interesting as I had no knowledge of Pet Sounds at the time and how it linked to this album (I was also listening to The Riddle by Nik Kershaw but that a different story.
    Really can’t rank the tracks in order but Tomorrow never knows makes my brain explode every time I hear it, it scared the s**t out of me when I heard it as a kid. For no one make me cry, Eleanor Rigby – Listen to the Yellow Submarine Songtrack version, Jawdropping!, Taxman – definetly written by George, he was always moaning about money in interviews.
    As for Yellow Submarine this really needs to be reassessed,it’s much more cleverer than people give it credit for, if it had been on Sgt pepper it would be mentioned the same way as Mr Kite and Lovely Rita

  5. G.E.P. says:

    Almost my same list. Except for Tomorrow Never Knows. For me is number 1. Is a very weird track, but works just fine. To many layers of sound. Fantastic task duplicate in stereo, the original mono mix.

  6. richie says:

    MORE LISTS, MORE LISTS, MORE LISTS…..I love `em.

  7. richie says:

    Right, I`ve got that lists thingy out of my system.

    Here`s my top 5, which of course is more informed than yours Paul `cos I`ve been listening to it longer;

    1. And Your Bird Can Sing.
    2. I`m Only Sleeping.
    3. Tomorrow Never Knows.
    4. For No One
    5. Taxman

    The top 4 will never vary, Eleanor Rigby, Here, There…, She said & Doctor Robert my be my No. 5 from time to time.

    Revolver The Beatles best maybe, maybe not but if any other band had recorded `Revolver` it would be their best album. Easily.

  8. Daltronica says:

    Glad to know I’m not the only one who finds the piano on “I want to tell you” really grating. Where was George Martin when that one was being laid down. Great article, would love to read more.

  9. Ollie Carlisle says:

    Well l enjoyed reading this even if others don’t like lists. I still wouldn’t buy Q though!

    The thing that’s always struck me about Revolver is that, for me, the music doesn’t quite match the cover. Don’t get me wrong, it’s a great picture, but I’ve always had a nagging feeling that as a collection of songs it deserves something more colourful to match up to the variety of sonic images. I guess I’m probably in the minority on this!

  10. G.E.P. says:

    I made a playlist with the album plus the single (paperback writer & rain). First the rock songs and then the ballads. Sounds so good to me.

  11. James says:

    Has always been my favourite Beatles album. I can’t complain too much about your list Paul other than you being overly generous with Taxman. Otherwise, spot on.

  12. Philip Cohen says:

    Actually, this album was ranked #1 in the 500 greatest albums of all time by Rolling Stone Magazine.(#2 was “Marvin Gaye-What’s Going On” & #3 is “The Beach Boys-Pet Sounds”). Suffice to say, “Revolver” is a pop music masterpiece.

  13. Stevie B says:

    I absolutely adore I Want T Tell You, but there’s nay a bad, or even average, track on the album.

  14. Lee Taylor says:

    Best batch of songs McCartney contributed to any Beatles album (or any album, period), in this listener’s opinion.

    • Marco says:

      What about Abbey Road’s Side 2? This is to my the best McCartney ever, in an album that has also the best Harrison.

  15. Just Sayin' says:

    If you’re not careful, you’re going to lure more people over here from the Steve Hoffman forums. Then you’ll be sorry…

  16. Mark says:

    Enjoyed the list Paul. Would have ‘For No One’ higher though. ‘Good Day Sunshine’ is spot on. still prefer Abbey Road though…

  17. RJSWinchester says:

    I’m not a massive fan of The Beatles but Revolver is a very good album. My favourite is ‘Taxman’ which, 14 years later, became one of Paul Weller’s finest moments.

  18. baward says:

    I think that both Rubber Soul and Revolver are better that Sgt.Peppers (but its a close run thing.)

    She Said She Said: aside from the alliteration, I think that’s another example of an English literary device that I can’t remember the name of right now! ‘She Said’, ‘Said She’ etc.

    Taxman: I wonder if George minded that the only song of his to lead off a Beatles album featured a guitar solo by his usually bass-playing bandmate?

  19. Chris Straub says:

    The shortened American LP was the first LP I ever owned and nearly thirty years after the CD made the UK track lineup standard worldwide, I still am thrown off by the presence of ‘Doctor Robert’ and ‘And Your Bird Can Sing.’ Funny, since I have listened to the CD many more times than I ever listened to the LP. Those early memories sure do stick.

    • Chris: Makes sense to me. I originally owned David Bowie’s Pin Ups on 8-track; even though I bought the Ryko CD reissue when it came out in 1990, the original LP sequence still sounds wrong to me…

      • Mick says:

        Same here – I originally owned Bowie’s Pin-Ups on 8-track, and when I finally got the CD, the original LP sequencing threw me. Same with Goats Head Soup by The Stones.
        As for Revolver, I always chuckle to myself when I see Dr. Robert, And Your Bird Can Sing and I’m Only Sleeping mentioned in the same breath. Those are Yesterday And Today tracks (ducks in the event of flying shoes…)!
        Seriously tho, being in the US, to this day I cannot get used to the “standardised” UK version of The Beatles catalog that replaced the US Capitol versions in the 80’s when the first CD’s came out.

    • Billy Dojcak says:

      Along with the US Rubber Soul…

  20. Looks like you lost a bit of text there at the top—at least, in my browser (Chrome, on an iMac)…

  21. Of course, ‘those Rock ‘n’ Roll [Music] albums’ didn’t become albums (plural) until the later budget reissues…

  22. aubrey says:

    Lists! A great excuse to stop doing what you’re supposed to be doing… although the *ahem* correct order of merit is:

    I’m Only Sleeping
    Eleanor Rigby
    Tomorrow Never Knows
    For No One
    And Your Bird Can Sing
    Dr Robert
    Here, There and Everywhere
    She Said, She Said
    Taxman
    Got To Get You Into My Life
    Good Day Sunshine
    Yellow Submarine
    Love You To
    I Want To Tell You

    And this remains one of the great scenes in TV history…
    https://youtu.be/rLLL9DKpUa4

  23. Josh says:

    re: your ‘Taxman’ comments…. I had always read, and I think correctly, that Nowhere Man was the first Beatles song to be about something other than romantic love.

  24. Mike the Fish says:

    I enjoyed this article. The top and bottom entries were not what I expected! I wonder if Paul was at a song writing peak on this album. For No-One is gorgeous. I would prob out Love You To at the bottom. I’d forgotten about I Want To Tell You, so that would probably be next. Taxman is great if somewhat unbalanced on the stereo mix.

  25. Avitom says:

    There’s God = The Beatles, there are the angels = the songs. The angels are all good, so are the Songs thus, you can not pick up you’re favorite angel or your favorite song. All are an equal and part of the puzzle called Revolver. Take out “Submarine” and there is no Revolver, take our TNK and there is no Revolver. Hope you got my drift.

  26. HDN says:

    I confess, that I always skip Got To Get You Into My Life. It really doesn’t belong here in.

  27. Tim-meh says:

    Its a better sleeve than Sgt Pepper’s.

  28. Dave Gilmour's Cat says:

    Surely ‘Yellow Submarine’ should come last. I always think this song stops the album being a masterpiece.

  29. J says:

    OUCH!!! A list? Must have been a really slow day @ the SDE office huh? Whats next? A list of Elton’s top 10 pair of glasses?

    I will play along (sort of) by noting that the best version of Tax Man can be found on the Black Oak Arkansas LP Live Mutha. It is an acquired taste & it might take a few listens (and a few pints) but it is my fave version of the song
    J

    • Paul Sinclair says:

      So discussing Revolver on its 50th anniversary represents a “slow” news day!? SDE is hardly chock-full of lists, so not too sure what the issue is. Judging from the comments the majority seemed to enjoy this piece.

      • J says:

        Paul U R right, your readers have responded on the whole. U have a great web site that most of us refer to daily. Keep it that way. There is a “list” of the best Pink Floyd tracks on the Hoffman site that has been going on for over 4 years. It is dreck
        Fatoldbloke and I are just giving friendly advice that may serve U well
        Cheers
        J

        • Paul Sinclair says:

          Thank you. All feedback greatly appreciated :)

          • J says:

            It is always a pleasure
            If you really want to torture yourself give a listen to the Black Oak Arkansas version of Taxman. Most Beatle fans find it horrid. But…if you consider that electricity did not arrive in their neck of the woods until the 1950s it is amazing that a bunch of backwater boys were the biggest Beatles fans ever. The reach of the Beatles knows no bounds
            J

      • Mosthaf says:

        The issue is that some people think that rankings suck. Full stop. Writing a good review is an entirely different matter and more difficult but can be enlightening. But you have to be good. I am siding with J: don’t go there. It’s your site of course and you can do whatever you want.

    • RJSWinchester says:

      Judging by the music tastes of Mr Sinclair and most of the contributors of the comments on this site, a 50th Anniversary reassessment of Revolver is not unreasonable. Much of the music discussed here falls out of my scope of interest (the last two box sets I bought were by Egisto Macchi) but I’m always impressed by the in-depth knowledge of Mr Sinclair and the many contributors.

    • Julian H says:

      I will play along by noting that the worst version of Taxman can be found on the Saga LP Pleasure & the Pain. And I’ll add that I’m a HUGE Saga fan, but almost the entire album is the definition of a band lost in the wilderness. Why they decided, twenty years into their career, that they wanted to cover a Beatles song, I’ll never understand. But there’s even worse songs on that album!

      :)

  30. RJSWinchester says:

    Over the past 20-25 years Revolver has become widely regarded as the best album by The Beatles. I remember years ago before the internet when lists were few and far between and restricted to printed media, Sgt Peppers was ALWAYS voted No.1 above all other albums. I’m not overly familiar with the work of The Beatles except for the hits, Revolver and The White Album (particularly the first disc) but what I do like about Revolver is the bass guitar and the sing-along-at-the-top-of-your-voice quality of songs such as ‘And Your Bird Can Sing’ and ‘Got to Get You Into My Life’. It’s just the right mix of Rock and Pop but with an edge. It wouldn’t feature in a list of my Top 50 albums but it wouldn’t be far off.

  31. Robert says:

    Its nice to see this album has gotten more recognition as time goes by. When I was a young teen
    in the 1980’s it seemed universal that Sgt Pepper was the Beatles best. I would place that album 4th or 5th behind Revolver (1st) Rubber Soul (2nd) Abbey Road (3) White Album (4) but any could justifiably lay a claim to the best. I think its impressive how many are the songs are familiar to millions even though there were only a few singles released from those albums – In the States Revolver had one single released here, not counting Got To Get You Into My Life which was released 10 years after the album, Sgt Pepper had zero singles, White Album had zero, Abbey Road had one single and Rubber Soul had one single. After 50 years those albums are still among the best ever.

  32. ANDREW r says:

    Put Rain and paperback writer on take Love you to and Gotta off
    Now it matches the surrealism of it’s cover and is deserving of its plaudits.

  33. ANDREW r says:

    never understood those missing off Revolver plus Strawberry/penny lane off Sgt pepper
    With those additions they are both pretty much perfect. Add in Rubber Soul and that must be the best 3 lp run ever by a band. Of course someone else is going to…… point me to the exit?

    • Paul Sinclair says:

      I really enjoyed listening to Revolver yesterday for that piece. Sometimes you go through periods where you’ve ‘had enough’ of The Beatles (largely due to over familiarity), but not having listened to it for a while I was grinning like a cheshire cat and just LOVING IT :) And yes, an amazing trio of albums…

  34. ANDREW r says:

    Also bit of a missed opportunity for Apple.Where is the 50th anniversary special
    edition featuring outakes plus the alt version of TNK ? Money to be made there boys!

  35. Stevie B says:

    Josh,

    Wouldn’t Help! be an earlier example of a Beatles song that is not about romantic love? Also, I only found out last week that the individual Music for Pleasure (budget) Rock ‘n’ Roll Music albums feature many different mixes, specially created by George Martin for the original double album, but rejected by Capitol execs. Damn, the means I’ll have to and seek them out from my local specialist vinyl collectors record store!

  36. Adam shaw says:

    The album runs perfectly but I always skip Yellow Submarine.
    Taxman (although dated cause of political points )is my favourite.

  37. Gareth says:

    It is a terrific album. I’ve never been that impressed with ‘Tomorrow Never Knows’ though. Probably in my 5 worst Beatles tracks. I love ‘Got to Get You Into My Life’. A great vocal from Paul on that one. In addition to ‘Revolver’ improving with age I think ‘A Hard Days Night’ has also grown in stature over the years. Easily the greatest band there’s been. No-one else comes close.

    • Paul Sinclair says:

      A Hard Day’s Night is a phenomenal record. Beatles for Sale with the covers padding it out a bit, felt like a step back, despite the maturity of some of the Lennon-McCartney numbers. Obviously their workload was off the scale, so with the touring, filming, promotional and two albums a year commitments (plus non-album singles!) there was only so much they could physically do.

  38. Steven C says:

    Your list illustrates nicely why I always preferred John. I’m Only Sleeping is so much better than stuff like Good Day Sunshine. There are no syrupy and cheesy Beatles songs penned by John. I mean, we all love Paul and he’s one of the best of all time, but John’s songs were a bit more meaningful and artistic. I do think Paul’s “Here, There and Everywhere” should be #2 though…

  39. Spiderbite says:

    Any list ranking these songs that doesn’t have “Tomorrow Never Knows” as number one is not worth reading.

    Now go smoke some weed or drop acid and get back to me. :)

    • Paul Sinclair says:

      It’s a great recording… but not the best ‘song’ on the album.

      • David Mc says:

        In a harmonic and melodic sense TNK is probably the least interesting song on the album. It’s not really something that you would play solo on a piano or guitar. But looked through a rhythmic, textural and process lens, it is astounding and predicts genres like techno. For that reason it is probably the most important track on the album.

  40. Fatoldbloke says:

    I just put the CD in and press play.
    No need to decide what track is better or whatever.
    Don’t go down the path The Hoffman Forum do.

  41. Ian Mears says:

    Nice piece to read on a Sunday morning over breakfast (hello from Sydney). Regardless of the order or the ‘list’ discussion, I like reading music fan’s opinions on music. Your introduction to the album way back when via a tape in the wrong order brought back memories. And those cassettes had such limited booklets. I was only 9 when Lennon was killed and my love of The Beatles began, but even by 1987 when there was the fuss over the anniversary of Pepper I remember telling anyone that would listen that Revolver was a better Beatles album because each of them contributed, and in many ways it was each of them at their best as a part of the sum. It’s not their best 14 songs, but it’s the best collection of songs on an LP.
    It had never occurred to me that Got To Get You Into My Life didn’t quite fit right. Imagine if Paperback Writer / Got to Get You Into My Life had been a double A side single, and Rain had been on the LP instead. What a band.

  42. DaveM says:

    Gut wrenching Paul, intuitive and cynical John, mystic George, genius beats by Ringo, too hard to call on whats best and this is what separates the Beatles from all else.

  43. Rick R says:

    So the US version of Revolver is missing the best track…

  44. AnthonyC says:

    I was introduced to this album by my dad.

    He gave me a mono first pressing which I believe has a different take of one of the tracks.

    I like the Stereophonics version of I’m only Sleeping.

    • Paul Sinclair says:

      Your Dad is more generous than mine. He has all his original mono pressings sitting in a cupboard somewhere (he doesn’t have a turntable) but won’t give them too me…

    • Kenny says:

      The -1 matrix of the mono was available for a short period before being withdrawn and has the “Take 11″ version of TNK. Worth a bit now!

  45. scalp says:

    As a child Revolver was my first experience with Popular Music. I always think this one was the best album of the times. It’s definately my number one, (number 2 being Horse Rotorvator by Coil)

  46. Tom D says:

    This has become my favorite Beatles album, and my favorite album by anyone. The mono blows away the stereo. I also like to play it from the playlist I created that slots “Rain” after “Here, There and Everywhere,” and “Paperback Writer” after “I Want To Tell You.” And I also stuck that vibraphone fragment of “I’m Only Sleeping” (from “Anthology”) before “Good Day Sunshine.”

    I don’t mind the list, always good to see what someone else thinks. I’d have a hard time ranking these!

  47. Tim says:

    Not a fan of Yellow Submarine. Good Day Sunshine has a killer hook, especially towards the end when McCartney hits the higher notes (gooood day SUNSHINE! ) along with the drum and Rickenbacker duo. Agree about I’m Only Sleeping, especially after hearing the charming Anthology mix with the marimbas.

  48. Rob Batters says:

    If good day sunshine is the worst track on the album, this, as I’ve always thought, is the greatest 35 minutes ever committed to vinyl

    Pretty much perfect.

  49. kris says:

    I think ‘I Want To Tell You’ is one of the greatest songs ever written and recorded. Can you imagine any popular artists at this time to record a song on the top of their success with such a creative unusualy piano-chord? I think this is just an example of the greatnes and open minded thinking of The Beatles. WOW!

  50. Michael says:

    I know lists like this are a very personal thing but my favourite song on Revolver is also my favourite Beatles track ever as well as my second favourite John Lennon lyric and thats Tomorrow Never Knows. The weird thing is that it was the first song recorded for the album I think what a way to start a new record. (incidentally my favourite Lennon lyric is Watching The Wheels)

  51. Mark McKendrick says:

    *yawn*

    (not Revolver…. you lot).

  52. oystein says:

    just chipping in to say, 1) Don’t stop doing lists, as I like lists, 2) even to those who don’t like lists, the review of each song of such a key album ought to be worth a read.

    How do you rate the songs on Queen is Dead, Violator, Different Class, Raw Power, Man Machine, Bollocks or Neu! 75? Please let us know on the corresponding release date ;-)

  53. sgolston says:

    Just loving everyone’s comments & opinions. What a difficult, agonizing job to try to rank the songs on the single greatest sonic “long player” that’s ever been issued, IMHO. For me there’s no single ranking that will work. I could have a ranking for sheer song-writing genius (i.e., structure, melody, inventive use of pop elements), one for instrumental genius (has there ever been an album that has the sheer genius of bass impact combined with drumming brilliance?), and one for sheer emotion and fun (you know, like we used to hear these things when we had teen and pre-teen hormones coursing through our veins.. :-)

    It makes a BIG difference which frame I try to take. Yellow Submarine would be right up there for sheer fun, but holding up the bottom end from other perspectives (I mean, if you had a Beatles intro path anything like mine and first really listened when you were 9-10 yrs old in 1969-1970 or so, can you actually imagine your musical existence without Yellow Submarine in it?–even with all it’s shortcomings that’s simply preposterous to me!) The 1976 single release of Got To Get You Into My Life utterly ruined that song for me. Yet, on a vocal performance basis, I 100% agree with the commenter above who opined that it is one of Paul’s finest moments.

    But OK, having established the context for my disdain of a single list, Paul S.’s inspiration leads me to submit the following at this particular moment in time. Call this my blended ranking in terms of “can’t imagine the world without this track” (and believe me, I CAN’T imagine the world without Rain, so the PW/R single is IN for my list…):

    1) And Your Bird Can Sing (the absolute joy & exuberance of this song has never abated for me)
    2) For No One (the simple, singular beauty of the horn playing is still jaw-dropping)
    3) Rain (just sublime….)
    4) Tomorrow Never Knows (I changed the order of TNK & Rain a dozen times….)
    5) Here, There & Everywhere
    6) Eleanor Rigby
    7) Love You To (anybody else ever sit & contemplate why it isn’t “Love You Too”?)
    8) Paperback Writer (one of the first tracks to blow my young mind w/ it’s “Englishness”)
    9) She Said She Said
    10) Taxman (can’t imagine a better album opener w/ the count-in, cough, etc.)
    11) I’m Only Sleeping (some days, this might actually flip w/ AYBCS to demonstrate how tough this task is….)
    12) Good Day Sunshine (I can’t believe this is so low–I *love* this song!!)
    13) I Want To Tell You
    14) Doctor Robert (though I still think the “Well, well, well…” break is one of the most inventive things I’ve every heard in a pop song)
    15) Yellow Submarine (LUV Ringo’s vocal!)
    16) Got To Get You Into My Life

    Cheers!
    Steve G.

    • Tom D says:

      My sense of the “Love You To” title is (unless it is a spelling error) that it follows on from the final lyric:

      “I’ll make love to you / If you want me to.”

      In other words, George is hoping that the response would be, “Yes, I would love you to [make love to me].”

  54. Arthur O'Brien says:

    Sorry, I love Revolver but “Pepper” is still the better LP to my ears.

  55. Mikko Suhonen says:

    If John would have wanted his name in the credits of Taxman, he should have given George credit for all the input he had on Lennon/McCartney -songs. He didn’t write them. but otherwise he influenced the songs so much that nowadays he would have given credit in quite a many songs credited to John and Paul. F.eg. Paul has acknowledged his input on And I love her.

  56. Kenneth says:

    Just my opinion, but no way I can put Revolver or Rubber Soul ahead of Sgt. Pepper. I love them all, but Sgt. Pepper is special.

  57. Silver Dagger says:

    I’ve heard that And Your Bird Can Sing was a sly Lennon dig at Jagger and his famous girlfriend. Think about it.

  58. Ron says:

    Paul,

    Instead of ranked “lists” (you know they are just preferences and opinions, and they led to debate and negative comments) how about a list of each song and state ONLY what we LIKED about each song. Then, we would be celebrating the album and its content, and keep the negativity out of it.

    What do you think?

    • Paul Sinclair says:

      Don’t think things have been too negative, have they? Isn’t the debate about what’s ‘best’ the thing that makes it interesting? I think even if I hadn’t ‘ranked’ the songs, people would chip in with similar comments saying what they did and didn’t like. Surely you need to put a marker in the sand, to then spark some debate. I have no problem with people disagreeing with what I say, as long as people aren’t unpleasant about it and it’s a constructive and friendly argument.

      • Ron says:

        Sorry, I meant, what do you think about us stating what we liked about each song instead of a list. The former could help others enjoy the songs more, as there might be things some enjoyed about the songs that others haven’t thought of. I’ve seen this before, and people really seem to enjoy it more.

  59. Billy Dojcak says:

    Hmm, I recall only one song from Revolver was made into a feature length film. No matter how uncool, everyone knows what that submarine looks like. (It is also the first song my daughter sang) IMHO, Revolver is a little Paul-heavy. My daughter also knows who wrote what and Paul’s songs can be lightweight. I’ll stick with the Mono Boxes versions.
    Turning 50 must be important, even my wife mentioned it.

  60. Julian H says:

    Pleasantly surprised that you rate “Good Day Sunshine” the way I do as well. If it was influenced by “Daydream”, then boo since “Daydream” is a much better song.

    About “Got to Get You Into My Life”, I’ve gotten so used to the excellent reworking by Earth Wind & Fire that the Beatles original now sounds underdeveloped to me…

  61. Julian H says:

    My favourite Beatles album is Abbey Road, by the way…

  62. Walrus Gumboot says:

    Revolver is great. But both Paperback Writer and, especially, Rain were their top tracks of 66…

    Keep doing the lists, by the way… Ignore any miserable gets…

  63. StevieP says:

    “Eleanor Rigby” is definitely my favourite. It first captured my imagination when I was a child and I’ll always have a soft spot for it. I love everything else on that album… except for “Got to Get You Into My Life”. It probably doesn’t help that I actually heard that song ruined by at least one ’70s TV variety show host before I heard the original. I don’t remember hearing Earth, Wind and Fire’s version. I’ll have to check it out.

  64. Harrison wrote ” Taxman ” as a protest against the high marginal tax rates paid by top earners like the Beatles, which were sometimes as much as 95 per cent of their income. McCartney wrote ” Yellow Submarine ” – a song he later characterised as a “kid’s story” – as a vehicle for Starr’s limited vocal range.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>