SDEtv: The Beatles / Abbey Road anniversary edition – unboxed

The Beatles / Abbey Road 50th anniversary super deluxe unboxing video

The 50th anniversary edition of The Beatles‘ 1969 album Abbey Road is released today and SDE is delighted to bring you this unboxing video of the 3CD+blu-ray super deluxe….

All six formats of the Abbey Road anniversary edition are out now. What are you thoughts on the new package? Leave a comment.

Compare prices and pre-order

The Beatles

Abbey Road - 3CD+blu-ray super deluxe edition


Compare prices and pre-order

The Beatles

Abbey Road - 3LP vinyl box set


Compare prices and pre-order

The Beatles

Abbey Road - vinyl picture disc


Compare prices and pre-order

The Beatles

Abbey Road - 2CD deluxe edition


Compare prices and pre-order

The Beatles

Abbey Road stereo remix - single vinyl LP


Compare prices and pre-order

The Beatles

Abbey Road stereo remix - single CD


Abbey Road 50th anniversary edition 3CD+Blu-ray super deluxe edition

Disc 1 (CD) : 2019 Stereo Mix

1. Come Together
2. Something
3. Maxwell’s Silver Hammer
4. Oh! Darling
5. Octopus’s Garden
6. I Want You (She’s So Heavy)
7. Here Comes The Sun
8. Because
9. You Never Give Me Your Money
10. Sun King
11. Mean Mr Mustard
12. Polythene Pam
13. She Came In Through The Bathroom Window
14. Golden Slumbers
15. Carry That Weight
16. The End
17. Her Majesty

Disc 2 (CD): Sessions

1.     I Want You (She’s So Heavy) (Trident Recording Session & Reduction Mix)
2.     Goodbye (Home Demo)
3.     Something (Studio Demo)
4.     The Ballad Of John And Yoko (Take 7)
5.     Old Brown Shoe (Take 2)
6.     Oh! Darling (Take 4)
7.     Octopus’s Garden (Take 9)
8.     You Never Give Me Your Money (Take 36)
9.     Her Majesty (Takes 1-3)
10.  Golden Slumbers/Carry That Weight (Takes 1-3 / Medley)
11.  Here Comes The Sun (Take 9)
12.  Maxwell’s Silver Hammer (Take 12)

Disc 3 (CD): Sessions
1.     Come Together (Take 5)
2.     The End (Take 3)
3.     Come And Get It (Studio Demo)
4.     Sun King (Take 20)
5.     Mean Mr Mustard (Take 20)
6.     Polythene Pam (Take 27)
7.     She Came In Through The Bathroom Window (Take 27)
8.     Because (Take 1 – Instrumental)
9.     The Long One (Trial Edit & Mix – 30 July 1969) (Medley: You Never Give Me Your Money, Sun King, Mean Mr Mustard, Her Majesty, Polythene Pam, She Came In Through The Bathroom Window, Golden Slumbers, Carry That Weight, The End)
11.  Something (Take 39 – Instrumental – Strings Only)
12.  Golden Slumbers/Carry That Weight (Take 17 – Instrumental – Strings & Brass Only)


Audio Features:

– Dolby Atmos
– 96kHz/24 bit DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1
– 96kHz/24 bit High Res Stereo (2019 Stereo Mix)

The Beatles / Abbey Road 50th anniversary edition 3LP vinyl box

Abbey Road 50th anniversary edition 3LP vinyl box

LP ONE: Side 1 (2019 Stereo Mix)
1.     Come Together
2.     Something
3.     Maxwell’s Silver Hammer
4.     Oh! Darling
5.     Octopus’s Garden
6.     I Want You (She’s So Heavy)

LP ONE: Side 2 (2019 Stereo Mix)
1.     Here Comes The Sun
2.     Because
3.     You Never Give Me Your Money
4.     Sun King
5.     Mean Mr Mustard
6.     Polythene Pam
7.     She Came In Through The Bathroom Window
8.     Golden Slumbers
9.     Carry That Weight
10.  The End
11.  Her Majesty

LP TWO: Side 1 (Sessions)
1.     I Want You (She’s So Heavy) (Trident Recording Session and Reduction Mix)
2.     Goodbye (Home Demo)
3.     Something (Studio Demo)
4.     The Ballad of John and Yoko (Take 7)
5.     Old Brown Shoe (Take 2)

LP TWO: Side 2 (Sessions)
1.     Oh! Darling (Take 4)
2.     Octopus’s Garden (Take 9)
3.     You Never Give Me Your Money (Take 36)
4.     Her Majesty (Takes 1-3)
5.     Golden Slumbers/Carry That Weight (Takes 1-3) / Medley)
6.     Here Comes The Sun (Take 9)
7.     Maxwell’s Silver Hammer (Take 12)

LP THREE: Side 1 (Sessions)
1.     Come Together (Take 5)
2.     The End (Take 3)
3.     Come and Get It (Studio Demo)
4.     Sun King (Take 20)
5.     Mean Mr Mustard (Take 20)
6.     Polythene Pam (Take 27)
7.     She Came In Through The Bathroom Window (Take 27)
8.     Because (Take 1 Instrumental)

LP THREE: Side 2 (Sessions)
1.     The Long One (Trial Edit & Mix – 30 July 1969)
2.     Something (Take 39 – Instrumental – Strings Only)
3.     Golden Slumbers/Carry That Weight (Take 17 – Instrumental – Strings & Brass Only)

The Beatles / Abbey Road 50th anniversary edition 2CD deluxe

Abbey Road 50th anniversary edition 2CD deluxe edition

CD 1: 2019 Stereo Mix
1.     Come Together
2.     Something
3.     Maxwell’s Silver Hammer
4.     Oh! Darling
5.     Octopus’s Garden
6.     I Want You (She’s So Heavy)
7.     Here Comes The Sun
8.     Because
9.     You Never Give Me Your Money
10.  Sun King
11.  Mean Mr Mustard
12.  Polythene Pam
13.  She Came In Through The Bathroom Window
14.  Golden Slumbers
15.  Carry That Weight
16.  The End
17.  Her Majesty

CD 2: Sessions
1.     Come Together (Take 5)
2.     Something (Studio Demo)
3.     Maxwell’s Silver Hammer (Take 12)
4.     Oh! Darling (Take 4)
5.     Octopus’s Garden (Take 9)
6.     I Want You (She’s So Heavy) (Trident Recording Session & Reduction Mix)
7.     Here Comes The Sun (Take 9)
8.     Because (Take 1 Instrumental)
9.     You Never Give Me Your Money (Take 36)
10.  Sun King (Take 20)
11.  Mean Mr Mustard (Take 20)
12.  Polythene Pam (Take 27)
13.  She Came In Through The Bathroom Window (Take 27)
14.  Golden Slumbers/Carry That Weight (Takes 1-3 / Medley)
15.  The End (Take 3)
16.  Her Majesty (Takes 1-3)

The Beatles / Abbey Road 50th anniversary single CD

Abbey Road 50th anniversary edition single CD edition

2019 Stereo Mix
1.     Come Together
2.     Something
3.     Maxwell’s Silver Hammer
4.     Oh! Darling
5.     Octopus’s Garden
6.     I Want You (She’s So Heavy)
7.     Here Comes The Sun
8.     Because
9.     You Never Give Me Your Money
10.  Sun King
11.  Mean Mr Mustard
12.  Polythene Pam
13.  She Came In Through The Bathroom Window
14.  Golden Slumbers
15.  Carry That Weight
16.  The End
17.  Her Majesty




183 responses to SDEtv: The Beatles / Abbey Road anniversary edition – unboxed

  1. smorrissey says:

    Thank you very much for letting us know and we are very sorry to hear that you have playability issues with your Abbey Road Blu-Ray. There seems to be only an extremely small percentage of folk reporting problems…..

    ok well i’m not planning being one of them so not sell from my side. First the Pink Floyd box and now this…. I guess that’s the reason why this Abbey Road box is on sale on amazon….

  2. smorrissey says:

    I was planning to buy this today but so many complaints about faulty discs…guess i’ll pass. yes, optimal media strikes again.

  3. For anyone wanting this for a bargain go onto music magpies ebay shop it’s £80.32 when you get to checkout enter POPULAR20 in the voucher code section and you’ll get £16.06 discounted so you get it for £64.26!!! (Inc delivery) …the code runs out tonight (May be UK only??)

  4. Ben says:

    Here’s an information for everyone whose Blu-Ray disc of the Abbey Road Deluxe Box is defective:

    You just need to contact Universal Music (send an email to and ask for a replacement disc. They are very friendly and will send you a new BR disc.

    This is their answer to my inquiry:

    Thank you very much for letting us know and we are very sorry to hear that you have playability issues with your Abbey Road Blu-Ray. There seems to be only an extremely small percentage of folk reporting problems, thankfully, and of course we will replace your Blu-Ray immediately (so you can complete your fabulous box set!).
    Just let us have your address and we’ll courier a replacement to you by return and send you the tracking details. Each replacement will be tested beforehand (a job I love as I’m a massive Beatles’ fan).
    Again, please accept our apologies but do let us know if you have any further issues.

    • Beatlearmin says:

      Thanks for your information. They really are very friendly and have dispatched the new BluRay the same day I asked for replacement.

    • Iain says:

      I’ve just bought the set from Amazon UK, but the Tracking Details show that it’s coming from France!!
      Do you know if the Blu Ray problem is just with pressings from a specific plant/location?
      I guess that as Universal Music know about this, they will replace it wherever it’s from!

  5. PFRW says:

    On Optimal Media only bunglers work

    Wait for the new Pink Floyd…

  6. Noel says:

    Flaw in the vinyl on side 3 of mine which makes a thrum sound on each revolution. So it’s going back. Unfortunately it’ll have to go back to Amazon Germany, so that should wipe out my saving on the postage. :-(

  7. Pieter van der Velde wzn says:

    I’ve just enjoyed in the Amsterdam Ziggo Dome the Analogues doing Abbey Road. To paraphrase Yes, I was Close to the Beatles.

  8. CJL says:

    Just gotten ‘round to playing the blu disc & I have the same problem as Ralf – two parallel lines that look like either a pressing fault or glue residue. Have contacted Amazon to see if they’re aware of the problem(s) & to see if they can just replace the blu disc.
    Paul, I take it that you’ll let us know if there’s any ‘official’ acknowledgement of the problem(s)?
    Brilliant site by the way. Keep up the excellent work.

  9. Dennis Yardley says:

    I think the Giles Martin ‘remix’ of the actual Abbey Road album is a bit heavy handed. In places The tracks sound and feel different to the original and I find that disappointing as his work on Sgt Pepper and The White Album was so good and respectful.
    Just my thoughts

  10. Adey says:

    Why can’t they do a super deluxe box set of their BEST album, revolver?
    Sorry, i had to ask (again!)

    • Alan Mitchell says:

      I was listening to that one yesterday. It’s not my favourite (i have Sgt Pepper, Revolver, White Album, Abbey Road and Help).

      With Prince there’s a general consensus of his greatest album regardless of whether it may be a person’s favourite. Is this the same with the Beatles?

  11. Keith says:

    Great packaging but the ble ray is a disaster. Could not get it to play on my LG found a workaround and played fine up to golden slumbers then stopped could not select any of the tracks past that.

    The menus are possibly the worst I have seen.

    Have returned to amazon to get a replacement.

    It appears that optimal in europe just don’t have any quality control.

    • Thilo says:

      Hi Keith, my bluray does not work, too.
      I have a pioneer player, the disc starts only sometimes, the apple logo appears only in a little part (top left edge), then after a few seconds the disc sometimes plays the stereo mix, but it does not allow to use a surround mix or to skip tracks. I got my copy from JPC Germany, they want me to send just the bluray back to them. If you look on the backside of the disc it seems to be an pressing error on the top, can you see that too?

    • Ralf says:

      Mines the same problem. Blu-ray back to for replacement disc.
      Greetings ralf

  12. Alan Mitchell says:

    This is the first time I’ve heard the album. Bought the 2cd set. It’s only recently I’ve started to buy any Beatles although i do have a third pressing of Sgt Pepper (with two lots of inserts somehow).

    Well with no history to compare it to i must say it sounds wonderful. The drums are, excuse my French, fucking amazing. The whole album leaps out at me (new Naim cd player helps) in fact. And the songs are as beautiful as any other Beatles’ songs I’ve heard.

    (I did play the cd in the car this weekend. Glad i don’t have a hifi that sounds like that is all i can say.)

    Of course now I’m wondering how the original sounds. Any pointers as to which pressing i should look for with regards a vinyl?

    PS: the drums really are fucking amazing by the way ;)

    • Sean Davey says:

      Alan – it was only a few months before these sessions that Ringo left the band. Lennon was asked whether Ringo was the best drummer in the World and he replied – “he’s not even the best drummer in the band”. They made up of course and Ringo came back.

  13. Jarmo Keranen says:

    Here in Finland Maxwell’s Silver Hammer was recorded by Vesa-Matti Loiri in 1973 and name of the song was Paulin taikakaulin. In English it could be read Paul’s Magic Rolling Pin.

  14. Adam says:

    The vinyl cover in the 3LP set replicates the original sleeve without Her Majesty labelled. No mis-aligned Apple though!

  15. Jurg says:

    Remixing albums has been done before. In 1997 The Beach Boys released the stereo mix of Pet Sounds (the first band who did that?) The album only existed in mono till then. They did that again with other albums in 2012. I bought them all because I’m a fan. Mike Oldfield released other mixes of his first albums. Is it better? I don’t care. It’s another listening experience and you should know that before buying it because you know the album so well in it’s original version. I only have the Sergeant Peppers box set. I’m happy with it but will not buy the other ones. I have the 2009 remasters and for me that’s enough. When they release Rubber Soul and Revolver in a box set … well … I will think it over again.

  16. bruce kelso says:

    hi, what would of been really a amazing experience would of been having all 137 plus of us in one room listening to this for the first time. the expressions would be priceless. not a dry eye there would be as the final notes faded away.

  17. Thilo says:

    I tried to listen to the surround mixes, but my pioneer player only plays the stereo mix, I’ m unable to get to the menues, the player automatically starts with “Come Together”. Is there anybody out there with a similar problem?

    • ralf says:

      Hey Thilo, i have also difficulties to play tracks beyond track 13. My Blu-Ray shows some kind of glue on the reading side, maybe residue from the cardboard Cover. There are two parallel lines left and right on the disc.
      I have contacted my customer service at “” and waiting for an answer from there.
      Greetings ralf

    • Paul E. says:

      @ Thilo – not sure what your Amp situation is but see if you can set that to “Auto” to decode the audio. Then, press the “Audio” button on your Pioneer Blu-Ray remote control to toggle through the available audio formats. Hope this helps you out.

  18. DaveM says:

    Played the three CDs from the SDE last night and actually really enjoyed them. The remix has only slight tweaks on the whole and I think the only fail is the vocal on Oh! Darling, where Macca goes for it and you can hear more distortion. The drumming though it has to be said is stunning, especially on The End, no wonder Ringo signed off on this. On the outakes, something struck me for the first time, how Come and Get it could’ve been an early seventies Wings single. Its not often I hear Wings in Beatles stuff. Anyhow, more than satisfied with this, especially with it being my first SDE of the year.

    • Jarmo Keranen says:

      It is great possibility to hear Wings in Beatles stuff or vice versa, because Paul McCartney was member and composer of both bands!

      • Paul Sinclair says:

        The point DaveM was making – and Elvis Costello picked up on this in an interview around the time of Flowers in the Dirt – is that Paul’s ‘style’ of music changed dramatically for Wings and he hardly referenced his Beatles style at all. There’s not a lot in the Wings output that sounds ‘Beatlesy’. There are a few (‘You Gave Me The Answer’ is similar to ‘Honey Pie’ for example) but not many.

  19. Dan says:

    How did the comments section get so toxic? Full of whinging and moaning.

  20. Tom D. says:

    Trying to figure out why it says “The Abbey Road” on the title page of the book (first page after the blank blue page; you show it for a fraction of a second). A later section is called “The Route to Abbey Road,” so it wouldn’t make sense for “The Abbey Road” to be there, too, unless it means “The One and Only Abbey Road,” which just really seems unnecessary. :)

  21. Sirpdwc says:

    I am very surprised at the negative tone of so many of these comments. This is the best album by the best band ever to make popular music. If you think it is too expensive then there is a simple solution: don’t buy it. You could always save up for the overblown, ludicrously-priced Pink Floyd’s The Later (And Indescribably Dull) Years which is 7 times more expensive and guaranteed to have you snoozing in 25 minutes.

    • Jorma S. says:

      Your and my mileage may vary, of course I love The Beatles and they’re truly one of the best ever. But..I still can’t think of them as the best ever, it doesn’t seem right towards other great artists, bands and composers. Besides, Abbey Road is one my favorites but it’s not actually even the best album from the Fab Four.
      There is no one that is best for sure..or wait it might be something but I won’t mention it yet as I don’t want to start any arguments.

  22. Fraser says:

    Having listened to the new 2019 remix, my appreciation for the superior quality of the original mix has only increased. ‘Improving’ the clarity of certain instruments has in this case been at the cost of the balance and integrity of the overall performance. I’m sticking to the 2009 master. Better I think to have focused on the outtakes, an analogue transfer of the master to vinyl and perhaps a high res digital stereo & fresh 5.1 mix. Shame also that they didn’t do a mix of HCTS with extra solo. Genuinely something of interest missed out.

    • Wayne Klein says:

      Well this set has everything that you mentioned except for the vinyl (separate) and the original album in high Rez. The blu Ray does have a fresh new multi channel mix and the stereo remix. This was designed to supplement not replace the original album. I personally have enjoyed the remix as it’s not like it was designed to replace the original mix since that’s still out there. I personally think this was the most sensible way to do this set.

      You can also preview it as the whole of the CD set was streaming at Amazon that way you can make an informed decision to buy this or not.

    • Jules(Rules) says:

      The problem with these mixes is not the mixing but the mastering. It’s simply unnecessary and removes part of what made the original performances great and lively. At least there’s a more dynamic version on the blu-ray but still…

  23. Wayne Klein says:

    So…it looks like a lot of people are having problems rippping the CDs from the 3 cd box set to their computer drives. Lots of errors. Wonder if there is a bad batch.

  24. Graham Piazza says:

    Hi everyone, I played the 3 vinyl box yesterday afternoon and I think it is great. The packaging is superb. The box is sturdy, great photo on the cover (a little grainy), the inner sleeves are black and poly lined. The actual vinyl looks great and plays perfectly. I did clean the sides with my Project cleaning machine before playing. There is no surface noise and all the discs are ruler flat.

    The music is wonderful. The sound is great – hard to believe it was recorded 50 years ago. My favourite tracks from the sessions are “Something”, “Come Together “ and the Trial version of the “Long One” ie “You Never Give Me Your Money” etc.

    The sessions show what a great band they were and how much attention they paid to small details. The sessions could have done as the finished product but they wanted to push for that little bit extra.

    It is a splendid time for Beatles fans.

  25. Paul kennefy says:

    Total rip off !! I love the Beatles but !!
    Over 80 quid for a book and 3 CDs !! Come on !!!!
    Village green was 11 disc for £110
    Joke !!!

    • Marc says:

      I guess it was clear that you get one book and 3 CDs (plus a blu-ray). So don’t buy it if it is a rip off for you.
      I think every CD 10$ and a book for 30$ makes 70$ is not a “rip off”. By the way I payed 67$ ( Think about how much work goes into this product – production, mixing, writing the book, design, advertising, distribution etc.

    • Chris Squires says:

      Its quite ridiculous to break every release down to what a CD or a book is worth. It happens on every thread. Streaming and downloading has robbed the industry of value and we as consumers are the poorer for it. But to say a Beatles CD, or a CD by anybody else for that matter, is only worth £x, $x or €x is exactly what is completely killing the physical music industry. As if the quality, desirability, historic importance or plain enjoy-ability of the music matters not one jot. How can it be that it’s the only the raw cost of the CD and how much one thinks that is worth that matters? Might as well stick .pdfs of Hansard on there then. It’s all the same.

      There are some (here un-named) artists that you could offer me a workaday 25CD set for £25 and I still wouldn’t bite. The number of CDs is irrelevant to those that love the music and how it is presented.

      • RJS says:

        “As if the quality, desirability, historic importance or plain enjoy-ability of the music matters not one jot”

        Yes, it’s a bit like those people who constantly question just how limited Limited Edition releases are, as if the quality, desirability, historic importance or plain enjoy-ability of the music matters not one jot”

        • Chris Squires says:

          ah, you can set your watch to dear old RJS, never one to miss an opportunity.

          What that opportunity is, I couldn’t possibly say.

    • Wayne Klein says:

      It’s also got a blu Ray with a lossless presentation of the remix. The book is quite handsome and is a coffee table high quality binding. I think it’s reasonable.

  26. Bruno says:

    All these comments really make me want to press the buy button but I won’t get fooled again by buying a beatles set on release. I will wait for the price to drop. It really sounds as if they have learnt from the previous releases to deliver a quality product without too much missing or too many sessions / takes of each song. May be they will release Let it be like the Dylan box set with every minute of music in the freezing film studio !

  27. Bob says:

    I have to admit I was quite underwhelmed . Sgt Pepper and The Beatles were quite wonderful . There are delightful moments , but those are expensive moments .

  28. Louis Crandell says:

    As you ask Paul, I express my critical opinion about the 3 deluxe editions of The Beatles.
    It is affectionate criticism, based on the basis that I buy everything that is published in The Beatles, including these 3 deluxe, because it is my eternal group.
    Sorry for my bad English :)

    Criticisms of deluxe editions:
    1st. Magical Mistery Tour and Yellow Submarine have been skipped in their 50 anniversaries. I understand that the market today is not able to process so quickly in releases that were in the 60s, and have sacrificed them for now.

    2nd. Completist collectors consider that these editions are not complete for several reasons:
    -The singles of the time are missing, and they have not had the same criteria when making the 3 deluxes.
    Sgt. Peppers includes the single of the time: Penny Lane / Strawberry Fields Forever, perhaps it would have also included All you need is Love, since they have not edited the deluxe edition of Magical Mistery Tour. In any case, in the rest of the editions the singles of the time are missing. In White Album the remixes of the single Hey Jude / Revolution are missing. And in Abbey Road the single The ballad of John & Yoko / Old brown Shoe is missing.
    – There are missing songs that appeared in the Anthology and are already part of the Beatles canon. For example, the long Mary Jane version is missing, replaced by a short shot on the White album. The Because version a capella and the long guitar solo of The End on Abbey Road are missing. I understand that in case of multiple takes of a song, to choose different from those published in the Anthology to provide an incentive with an unpublished take. In general, in the case of repeated shots, I think they have now been chosen superior to those of the Anthology.

    – “Sgt. Peppers” are missing songs that were originally published on other albums, but that should now appear in their original place, for example it should be Only a Nothern Song and possibly All Together Now. And more, since there is no deluxe edition of Yellow Submarine OST. And of course, the only unpublished song that remains of The Beatles: Carnival of Light should appear.

    – The 1968 songs that came out in single or in Yellow Submarine OST, which share sound with that album, are missing in White Album. It was necessary an additional CD in that edition entitled “The Beatles 1968”, with Hey Bulldog, Lady Madonna, The Inner Light, Across The Universe, and the single Hey Jude / Revolution. I would also include the Mary Jane version of Anthology, because it is now part of the group’s record canon.

    I suppose that the reason that these deluxe editions are not complete is due to economic reasons, to make profitable future remastered editions of the Anthology and Past Masters

    -More audiovisual content is missing to be completists: there are a couple of documentaries of “Sgt. Peppers” that could have been included. As well as the corresponding part included in the Anthology videos corresponding to each disc.

    3rd. It is not necessary to include CDs with the original mixes, but they should be included in the Blu ray. The Blu ray has enough space to store almost all the demo or session material that is generated in a recording, for the completists who want all the versions. Although only heard once in a lifetime, at least we have them in Blu Ray format for documentary purposes.

    4th. Lack of criteria in packaging, which have been cheaper with each new release. Sgt Peppers’s was very expensive, so they cut in the rest of the editions. The collectors would have liked them all more or less the same: a box that reproduces a tape box, the lenticular cover, and the memorabilia that appeared in the first one, in addition an independent book. Unfortunately that the White Album did not have the size 12×12, at least the poster would bent as in the original disc.

    5th. They have no criteria when deciding the editions parallel to the main one on CD. Different criteria for vinyl versions, double CD in each edition.

    6th. Regarding the sound of the new mixes, nothing to object to, I love them, but McCartney is seen to be behind, because they have inflated the sound of the bass, not that I don’t care at all.

    These are small complaints, in general I am moderately satisfied with these issues, put to note:
    Sgt. Peppers: 4,5 / 5
    White album: 4/5
    Abbey Road: 4/5

    As a final retreat, the Sessions could possibly go on BluRay / DVD, because they are recordings that are heard two or three times in life, initially out of curiosity rather than enjoyment. In those supports, you could put practically everything recorded. Then we all come back to listen to the original albums, remixed or not. How many times do we listen to the Anthology, if not for the unpublished songs?


    • John Kaelin says:

      I would love to hear everything too. However, going back to the Anthology series, the Beatles are creating an album experience with their outtakes, etc. It’s always been done in chronological order. They have created, at times, “new” from old to make even a simple take something new & fresh. Take the Anthology 2 Strawberry Fields sequencing for instance. Or how about the strings only Eleanor Rigby for Anthology and the orchestral session only for Something on Abbey Road. They simply don’t want to throw a hodgepodge of songs out there. I would think a streaming subscription service you be good for “everything” if they are never officially releasing certain items.

    • Geronimo says:

      Magical Mystery Tour was re-released in 2012 in the EP format with the bluray film restored. Remenber that MMT was not designed as an LP in the first place. Just later Apple addoped the US version of it as the “official Album”.

  29. ralf says:

    There is a hidden video on the Blu-Ray Track 2 – Something (Video) in all Audio Format available!
    On this Track Control Pad in the right direction! Then “Something (Video)” appears.
    Greetings Ralf

  30. Keith Ainsworth says:

    I just found the video for Something on the blu-ray. Just move down the menu to Something and press right. The word ‘video’ appears in black next to it. Press enter and you are taken to another menu for the video.

  31. Gareth says:

    Just finished listening to the picture disc. Very loud low frequency background whirring hum throughout. Anyone else notice this?

    • Steven Campbell says:

      Haven’t heard the picture disc of it yet but one thing I will say is that’s normal for a picture disc as it’s 2 bits of plastic with a paper printed picture in the middle and so you rarely get great sound out of picture disc, the only notable exception to that rule is the picture disc I have of Supertramp’s breakfast in America which is very well mastered and cut and as quite as a standard black vinyl version which I was astounded by.

      • Gareth says:

        Thanks Steven, I’ve pulled the Sgt Pepper picture disc and indeed it’s just the same. Oh well – looks nice anyway!

  32. John Kaelin says:

    Received the Super Deluxe set yesterday. Simply beautiful. I love the simple packaging. I think the packaging for each anniversary edition is reflective of the album. Abbey Road was the culmination of their entire career; marvelously executed and produced. Just really great and timeless music. I purchased mine from Amazon. I really had no choice. My independent music store closed a couple months ago. Barnes & Noble wasn’t accepting pre-orders & they were only expecting one copy. I couldn’t take a chance. So I’m hearing for the first time that there are slight differences in the Sgt Pepper Deluxe CD set as compared to the 2-CD set; the latter I never purchased. Is this true & did they do that for The White Album & Abbey Road. In addition, I do want all 99 takes of Maxwell as well. Lol.

  33. Ben Williams says:

    The new 2019 remix is a thing of beauty; a perfect album has somehow become more perfect. It’s like standing in Studio 2 and the Beatles are playing it right there and then for you, stunning.

  34. Fagnani Mauro says:

    Paul, why not a book in the vinyl box?! Why not a film protecion on cd?!

  35. Kevin says:

    I have seen run times of circa 44 mins for CD 2 and circa 23 mins for CD 3. Anyone know if that is correct? If so, they would comfortably go one disc.

    Enjoyed the video and thanks for posting.

  36. Tony says:

    I’ve only just got around to having a good listen to the White Album reissue, I saw the Abbey Road box in Banquet Records Kingston yesterday, ( great store, check it out if you’re near Kingston ), it looks great, I would like the option of a smaller box, the Police CD box & Aha 4 cd sets looks great, I’ve already ordered them.
    With a teenager today who spent his part time job wages on a £150 pair of trainers, and a tab for me of £30 for the Five Guys meal, I asked him if he would buy any of the music or box sets in Banquet and he couldn’t get around the concept of paying for music, I think we’re lucky these box sets are still being made. I’ll wait for the good old SDE alert for Abbey Road box. Happy Saturday folks.

  37. SynthGrizz says:

    Just bought my copy at the local Saturn store for EUR 79,99. They had 30 copies and I was allowed to open the carton to inspect the item for dents. No Amazon this time since they always send my damaged items.

    • Wayne Klein says:

      Amazon in the U.S. at least sent this in the cardboard protector and didn’t take the item out. Mine arrived just fine.

  38. J says:

    When this was released I was like 8 years old. It did not mean a lot to me at the time, I have never owned a Beatles disc until 2009 or so when they released the remastered CDs. This was the first one I ever listened to and I found it odd that I knew almost every song by heart. Amazing,

    I was at Target yesterday and the teenager in front of me had a Let It Be T-shirt on. When I gassed up the truck a gentleman @ least 80ish next to me has a Beatles bumper sticker.

    I know you get some Donnie & Debbie downers on your site but don’t pay them any mind. Your video for the unboxing is very good. I think 300 years from now this music will be just as relevant as it was upon release.

  39. andrew r says:

    Iam afraid i have to echo the great Glyn Johns who said
    “these remixes do not honour the originals ,the suggestion being there was something wrong with the original work” Also who exactly decided that Giles Martin had some genetic link to his fathers work that made him the obvious choice to work on the Beatles catalogue ?
    Sorry to be a party pooper but it just seems like an excuse to move product.
    Don’t even start me on the bbc’s fawning celebration this weekend “live from abbey rd that noted Beatles expert Zoe Ball …

    • Paul Sinclair says:

      Whatever people think of the remixes, unfortunately for Glyn Johns, The Beatles outrank him and they want the remixes and they want Giles Martin working on them. That said, I agree with people who say the original mix should really have been included as part of the overall offering.

      • andrew r says:

        Thanks you are correct Paul i failed to mention that in my
        reply . In fact am i correct in thinking that as these remasters come out they effectively
        replace all of george martins original mixes, which become unavailable to the general public?

    • Robert (not a doctor) says:

      to be honest I never get it when people argue about the remix, original mix etc. For me that all sounds soooo similar, i really don’t care much. I buy this box sets because of the additional material – the box itself, the book, the infos, the demos, the sessions…
      I have my blue box from 1979 and the vinyl mono box from 2012 (?). I am happy with that – don’t need “original” LPs or new “mixes” of the original LP.

    • Wayne Klein says:

      I disagree with Glyn. The original work is STILL there. I for one am happy to hear these. Heck, even George Martin wanted to fiddle with Rubber Soul and Help (even if his remixes were inferior to the originals). This gives fans the opportunity to hear an alternative mix that remains largely faithful to the original intent just cleaning up the generational loss of mixing to analog and using the ability to bring out subtle variations. If it was disrespectful, the original mix would have completely disappeared and be unavailable. It’s not. While “Abbey Road” is The Beatles album that probably needed a remix the least of any others, it does make something that may have fallen out of favor due to over exposure fresh again. It’s also about the money of course and the ones that have been remixed have been around their anniversary and their most popular albums. As to Giles, I think that it’s because he can both respect his father’s Original intentions and also find a balance for the current market, The Beatles own wishes, the estates of John and George. I think these sets have, largely, been a successful reinvention of the original album.

      At the end of the day, the original work is still there and no one is forcing anyone to buy these plus the band have made sure it is available in multiple configurations.

      • Andreas says:

        I have and like the new mix. My question was more about whether the originals will be commonly available for future generations, or whether the idea is that new listeners will always get to hear the remixes, and will have to get used LPs/CDs to hear the original band mixes.

  40. Mearsi says:

    Side 2.
    Achingly beautiful. Tears already and I haven’t even got through Here Comes The Sun

  41. Kevin Aston says:

    just to say I have Amazon prime but HMV were in excess of £90 whilst Amazon were over a tenner cheaper so ordered it from there. I nearly cancelled though because Amazon initially said that delivery would be 1st October, however yesterday morning I got an email saying it had been despatched yesterday and I would receive it same day, which I did. Packaged in two cardboard boxes and no damage at all. Just a thought , how many readers would prefer the hype sticker on the cellophane and not on the record box itself. Everytime I take the cellophane off I always take the sticker off and put it on the box itself and through the cellophane away. However some stickers tear when trying to remove them, so annoying. Thanks for the excellent site Paul.

    • RJS says:

      I wouldn’t mind some hype stickers actually printed on the sleeves of some releases. They do deteriorate over time andvcould potentially ruin a cover. Ideally, you’d have a sticker with a peel off back so you could make your own choice but I suppose then it wouldn’t serve its purpose as a hype sticker!

    • George glazener says:

      I find that an x-acto knife works well for surgically cutting the hype sticker from the cellophane. I rcvd my copy on Friday from, in a very strong cardboard box. No damage whatsoever and earlier than expected, so I’m happy with them. I’m hearing many bits of music I never noticed before, such as Paul’s bass work on “Bathroom window”, and some extended guitar noodling at the end of “You never give me your money”, just for starters. There’s a lot of neat stuff to discover here.

  42. Mark H. says:

    My only complaint is that they apparently used an MP3 version of Goodbye rather than a higher res version.

    Other than that, it sounds pretty good.

    • Paul Sinclair says:

      What’s your source on that?

      • Mark H. says:

        Steve Hoffman forum has (or had) spectrals of “Goodbye” that showed that it had passed through MP3 processing. I have heard (but cannot verify) that those posts have been scrubbed by the gorts there.

    • Mike says:

      “My only complaint is that they apparently used an MP3 version of Goodbye rather than a higher res version”

      Maybe because it is a home demo, and didn’t have higher resolution to work with?

      I really enjoyed the Atmos version though – the surround is used as it should be, sparingly.

      My major complaint is that the Sessions contents wasn’t included as a Hi-Res download with the Deluxe box, or for that matter why it wasn’t included on the Blu-ray, there is slightly more than 5GB of space available on the (single-layer) Blu-ray. Rather seems like nickel and diming for all they’re worth.

  43. Another Steve B says:

    Paul, some of these comments are priceless — some in a good way, some in a not as good way. Would really love to be able to stamp comments with reaction emojis!

  44. Aaron says:

    Anybody else have an issue on the 2nd CD?

    Here Comes The Sun (Take 9) and Maxwell’s Silver Hammer (Take 12) won’t play on my iTunes or load at all. Wondering if it’s just my disc that needs to be switched out or if there’s a production issue.


  45. Mearsi says:

    Yeah, I can do without 99 versions on a physical product, but I loved what they did on the Imagine CDs where they took you through the evolution of a song. I would definitely be keen for that to be done for all the Beatles albums.
    99 versions would be great for a straming service where you can create your own playlists of the interesting ones, but you also have to respect an artists choice when it comes to what they want people to hear

  46. jay k says:

    Received mine today, though I was listening on Qobuz before it arrived. I purchased the last 3 sde’s from both The Beatles and R.E.M. (my favorites) and find it interesting that in the physical sets the bonus audio tracks are only on cd but in digital stores and streaming services some (in the case of R.E.M. OOT & AFTP) or all (in the case of The Beatles) of the bonus tracks are available in hi-res versions. As awesome and generous as these sets have been, it sure would have been nice to make those bonus tracks available in hi-res on the blu-ray discs too instead of having to listen to them elsewhere. Oh well. At least there’s still the art, surround sound/Atmos…

  47. Gareth says:

    I keep leaving comments and you keep not publishing them. Did I say the wrong thing?!

    • Paul Sinclair says:

      Yes. Surprised you have to even ask…

      • Gareth says:

        I just gave some comments on my first listen – which is what you asked for. Did you not agree with them or is this over something else? There are a few ‘Gareth’s posting here.

        • Paul Sinclair says:

          Your comments were fine until the very end when you cheerfully suggested that illegal downloads were an acceptable option if you didn’t want to pay. Yep, I realise people do it, but I’m not going to endorse it on SDE by publishing a comment that makes out it’s okay.

          • Gareth says:

            Ah gotcha. Noted. I really really wanted to hear the alternative Long Medley, but just can’t justify the extra dosh for that one song. Blinking annoying!

          • Marc K. says:

            Gareth, anyone who wants to know, the free edition of webbased Spotify (so not on the phone, only on laptop/desktop) still offers a good listen to the complete 3cd version (deluxe) of Abbey Road, including ‘The Long One’. So no need to go illegal just for a good listen.

          • GARBAGE says:

            totally agree with you, Paul. The only thing is, you do endorse illegal uploads as you frequently link unofficially published videos from youtube. What’s that about?

          • Paul Sinclair says:

            If rights holders have an issue with YouTube videos it’s easy for them to get them removed. Part of the reason they don’t always do that is probably because they recognise it has a ‘promotional’ value even if unauthorised.

          • GARBAGE says:

            You may have a pointin some (not all) cases, but that doesn’t make it right. Particularly when an official video of the same song is just a few thumbnails down the list and you choose the unofficial (and, might I add, lower quality) one. This is something that has happened on SDE a few times, which is surprising as you don’t strike me as one to falter into lazy journalism

          • Paul Sinclair says:

            It’s a slightly weird issue for a music fan to get worked up about, if you don’t mind me saying. YouTube is full of interesting TV performances, live clips and homemade videos most of which the user doesn’t have the right to upload, but they stay there for whatever reason. The key difference is YouTube clips don’t really threaten physical sales as illegal downloading does. Why are you personally concerned about this issue?

          • GARBAGE says:

            I feel that is is decisively strange that more music fans don’t boycott these uploads and show a united loyalty to the owners of the work. I am personally concerned about this as I believe in credit where credit is due and I don’t like to see non-artists earning a single penny from Youtube’s flawed advertising scheme when they didn’t contribute one drop to the making of works of art. It’s a question of morality. Just because you can get away with it, doesn’t mean it should be done. Look at Trump, for example…

          • Paul Sinclair says:

            There is an easy mechanism for rights holders to get them pulled down – unlike stopping illegal downloading. What do others think about this debate…?

          • GARBAGE says:

            I would like to say a big thanks for filtering out comments that promote illegal downloading on your site, Paul. Before I forget to do so. You are doing your part there and I take my hat off to you. Hopefully others take note that ripping off the artists is essentially what’s killing the industry.

          • GARBAGE says:

            Anyway, back on track… This is a stellar release (as were the two prior) and I look forward to many years to come of SDEs from the greatest band of all time. To anyone questioning if the earlier albums will follow Let It Be, of course they will. They just started this off with the most famous one (Pepper) to see how it went. It’s gone great for three years, so maybe expect a short break after Let It Be (or maybe not) and an expanded Anthology (more outtakes, more demos, more live cuts) before the remaining albums get the SDE treatment. I’m also certain that Yellow Submarine & Magical Mystery Tour will have a place in this somewhere. What Paul said about MMT already having a deluxe release is only half true… That was the film, not the album/EP proper. Remember that Sign ‘O’ The Times was just released as a film SDE, but not an album SDE. This will also be coming down the line. ‘Shirley’s Wild Accordion’, anyone?

        • Ian Ellis says:

          If it’s just the long medley you want to hear Gareth, then sign up to Spotify for a free account and listen to it there. But there’s plenty more ace material than that on the SDE and it’s well worth the one-off outlay. For my money, I absolutely adore the version of Ballad of John and Yoko. Some nice studio chat too where John and Paul (who are of course on their own) refer to each other as Ringo and George. I remember George Martin at the end of the Anthology releases saying that it was all out there now, and that any further excavation of the archive would be scraping the barrel. Well, what wonderful scrapings we have had. I dearly hope that they loop back and SDE the earlier albums. Having heard the bootlegs of multiple versions of tracks from the hallowed Beatles recording session of 11th Feb 1963 (the Please Please Me recordings), I would dearly love all ten hours of those sessions. A slipcase containing 8 CDs of raw sessions, a couple more CDs to demonstrate how the overdubs were layered, a remix, the original stereo and mono for completeness, a good sturdy book. I’ve got £300 that I would willingly hand over without blinking.

          • Adey says:

            I’ve noticed that artists only seem to get the official stuff taken down on youtube, and leave the rarer unreleased stuff online, which is great for music fans like myself. I could spend a full saturday afternoon just browsing youtube, which to me is a modern day past time, comparable to the old days of browsing record shops to find interesting stuff i never knew existed! I think that if artists started pulling down the unreleased stuff, it would upset a lot of genuine fans, if the only option was to pay 20 quid A pop to line the pockets of a bootleg scalper. Fair play and respect to the artists for NOT having the stuff taken down, it certainly makes me want to buy their official stuff in return, And even serves as a taster for what COULD be released officially.
            I’m sure it gets more and more people interested in them, especially in this day and age!

  48. Musicmacca says:

    On another note , did anyone notice Paul’s recent interview on the Stephen Colbert show had ‘Getting closer’ as the intro music when he came on stage. A nod to ‘Back to the Egg’ or a clue to the next Superdeluxe edition ?

    • George glazener says:

      @musicmacca;Yes, I sure did catch that. I bet you’re right, we’ll see those SDEs out by Christmas. Love it…!! Bring it on

  49. Pete says:

    Thanks for the video Paul.

    Despite being an Amazon Prime member and ordering this on 8/8 mine isn’t now arriving until Monday. Has anyone else noticed that new releases pre-ordered from Amazon used to arrive on the day of release (Friday) but are now only expected to arrive on the following Tuesday? Or is it just me? I bought a discounted annual Prime membership in the Prime sale and now seem to be getting a second class postal service.

    I know it’s only a few days but when you’re out at work all week there’s a world of difference between receiving a new release, that you’ve been looking forward to, on the Friday/Saturday or having to wait ’til Monday/Tuesday when you’re back at work all day and can’t really spend time with it until the following weekend.

    • Steven_Wilsons_Prog_Cat says:

      i’m with you on this, Amazon in recent months have become atrocious with new releases…and price wise they seem to be getting a lot higher and not as competitive or attractive a proposition as they used to, i would advise you get in touch with their customer support state your unhappiness at the service etc, how being prime is meant to give you benefits like release day delivery, that’s what you paid for and now you have to wait till monay!, it will probably take you between 30mins to an hour if you do it via the chat option but if you speak directly via a call it should be quicker, you might get a little credit as an apology or a month free sub to prime, but i hear you loud and clear on amazon, it’s happening all the time now

      • Teddy G says:

        Arrived as promised on the release day, no atrocities observed. Opening!

      • Mark Scholes says:

        Definitely with you on this! Also, packaging has gone to pot as well…twice in one week I recieved Mark Ronson’s Late Night Feelings (not Abbey Road, I know, but I like it haha), loose in a box big enough to put a small tv in! Mind you, got £20 out of it from them!

    • Rowly75 says:

      Why don’t you go to an actual shop and buy it on the day it comes out, like I did, supporting independent retailers rather than some multi national out to kill every shop?…

      • Paul Sinclair says:

        Not everyone has a shop anywhere near them, so perhaps roll back on the judging of people.

        • Markyp says:

          The last time I ordered from a shop there were supplier issues and I got my releases weeks after release day.

        • Rowly75 says:

          Ok sorry, I wasn’t thinking about logistics (it was a Friday night…) I’m just very lucky to have a good record shop about a mile away from my home. I just worry about the reliance on buying online in general. Sometimes people don’t have a choice though I see that, I apologise

      • Steven_Wilsons_Prog_Cat says:

        @Rowly75 some people have to work, getting to a shop might not be convenient, there are not many record stores around anymore, i have to travel between 5 and 15 miles just to get to a record store, if i am working that day that’s just not feasible

      • JM says:

        Very fair point and that is what the industry is about -we do not need to support corporates and we should be free to say so! Everybody probably does an independent – support them as much as we can!

        • Paul Sinclair says:

          People aren’t ‘free’ to have a go at other SDE readers on this forum because of where they choose to shop. Comments like that won’t be published.

    • Richard Miller says:

      I am also an Amazon Prime customer and my pre-order won’t be delivered till Tuesday, however, it stated on their website that orders placed today (release day Friday) would be delivered next day Saturday! I contacted Amazon and received a long rambling email from them. I too was looking forward to listening to this over the weekend.

    • RODOLFO MARTIN says:

      Pete, I am in the USA. Mine was charged to my debit card two days ago and I received it today Friday 27th. Call Amazon and make a complain. They always give you some $$$ credit that you can use later. Good luck!

      • Francois says:

        That is interesting, maybe is it due to the third parties which deliver the parcels in the UK? Amazon France delivered the parcel yesterday to the collect point I had chosen. I have stopped getting deliveries at home or at work, as they are always late and I usually get a 1€ rebate if I choose the parcel not to arrive D+1.. I paid this SDE 68€ (that is around 64 pounds) so no complaint on my side..

    • Paul Taylor says:

      I agree. My Head Music exclusive is down for Nov 12 instead of the 8th.

    • RICHARD says:

      Same here. But they have now amended the date of delivery to tomorrow. I couldn’t wait so ordered a new set yesterday and it’s just arrived. I’ve cancelled the previous order. Worked out a couple of quid more and I can’t say I’m impressed with Amazon on this occasion. A bit sad maybe but it’s the Beatles and that’s justification enough. And no, we couldn’t go to a bricks and mortar outlet because the nearest one is 17 miles away and I have a wife and daughter to consider. Sorry if that offends anyone holier than myself.

  50. Tony says:

    Great review as always from Paul.
    To my mind it’s at least £2o overpriced so I will wait a while as it’s sure to come down in price.
    Plenty of other releases in the pipeline too, The Rolling Stones, Jeff Lynne to name but two.

    • peter chrisp says:

      Tony agree on prices but not much can be done. It is a little overpriced, out here in Australia the price is a little steep. But the good thing i have if i can use a term “Birthday” in October, & usually receive a gift voucher $50 which isn’t too bad. Thanks Paul too for your feedback & unboxing, brilliant stuff.

  51. DaveM says:

    Looks fantastic. I really like that style of slip case design, looks similar to the Who’s SDEs. My copy of the AR50 SDE arrives tomorrow. A day late from Amazon UK, but hey ho, what’s the use in worrying?

  52. Rowly75 says:

    The version of I want you is worth the admission price alone IMO! All four musicians plus Billy P at the top of their game.

  53. Tyrone says:

    Im struggling to find in depth reviews of this release / remix. I anticipated a wealth of opinions. Major muzo websites appear to be shy and not committing themselves.

    Are the surround mixes any good?

    I’m not fussed about the out-takes at the moment.

    Thanks in advance

    • Tyrone says:

      Has anyone in fact bought and listened to this?
      Its all good and well ‘claiming’ you bought it

      Whats the skinny?
      Who has in fact – bought – listened – and has an opinion to commit themselves to?
      Its getting impossible. Anyone?

  54. paul wren says:

    Why oh why isn’t the vinyl sized book in the vinyl version – unbelievable.

    • Steve says:

      I’m guessing the marketing thinking about the vinyl version is that it’s a “companion” to the CD/BD box. Assuming most people who buy the LP will also get the CD. So you don’t need 2 copies of the book.

      Not saying that’s right or wrong, just my speculation on why they’ve been doing this approach for the Beatles SDEs.

      • Graham Thomas says:

        The cynic’s view (ie mine) would be that if you want the vinyl (which I wouldn’t mind) plus the book (which I would like) you have to buy the CDs (which I don’t want or need). Would be nice if we could just choose the format we prefer and stick to it. Maybe the CD with a digital book and the vinyl with an analogue book! I would probably buy the vinyl if it had the book, but it doesn’t, so I won’t.

  55. Marc Kieser says:

    Thank you Paul, for the unboxing video.
    What’s you opinion on why they left off a proper remix of The Ballad of John & Yoko of this one, and Hey Jude? Revolution of the remix of The White Album? There will probibly be a compilation of some kind in the near future? What do you know, or think?

  56. Bogdan says:

    A stupendous package and a great way to honour this album! The outtakes on both this and the White Album reissue from last year are so good, that one can easily construct one (or more) alternate albums and hear the music in a different way. The remix is fine, not something essential, but nice to have, as it brings out certain details that may have been more veiled on the original mix (on first listen, Here Comes the Sun seemed to benefit the most from the remix, sounding more musical to these ears….if that makes any sense). The blu-ray disc in my box is defective and won’t play, so I’ll have to get a replacement. But it doesn’t matter, I am so happy this has come out and I got to hear it!

  57. Tom says:

    I was indecisive regarding purchasing this release but this unboxing video convinced me to take the plunge….plus I love the line “If you haven’t got a blu-ray player the question is,why not?!

  58. Ron van Rossum says:

    Thanks Paul for showing us this. Mine just arrivés …;-)

  59. Christophe says:

    Listening to the sessions lp’s’ very moving to hear such à great band playing so beautifully …near the end. Reissue of the century

  60. Chris says:

    Thanks Paul. This put me over the top on buying it now vs. waiting.

    A question: you mentioned that they appear likely to do _Let It Be_ next. Are there any signs at all that they’re going to go back and do any of the other albums?

    • Dr Volume says:

      Abbey Road studios keep talking about this “De-mixing” technology they’ve developed which can virtually separate out individual instruments recorded on the same track on the older tapes. So, technically once Let It Be has its SDE they could go back to Please Please Me and start issuing new stereo remixes and maybe even 5.1. I think they used this for the Hollywood Bowl to separate the music from the screaming a bit.

      Obviously there won’t be so much in terms of demos and out takes from the earlier sessions so these might not be megabox editions. I’d definitely like to hear a nicely balanced Stereo mix of Rubber Soul for instance without those hard-panned drums in one ear, vocals in the other which they retained for the 2009 discs, they sound really flat and no fun to listen to on headphones.

      • Chris says:

        Thanks. But I wasn’t really thinking of remixes so much as more content. I’d love to hear session recordings for e.g. _Rubber Soul_ or _Revolver_, for instance.

  61. adam shaw says:

    I will be unboxing my box set tonight with accompanying vocal backing from my wife saying “ haven’t you got that already !! “
    Can’t wait !

    • tom m hans says:

      followed by: “Seriously, another box set that you don’t need”?

    • 70s Guy says:

      That is funny. Luckily my wife gave up on the backing vocals when she finally noticed all of the versions of cd and vinyl I have of Ziggy Stardust neatly arranged in the “specials” cabinet next to the hi-fi.

      • Mark Scholes says:

        Haha! I guess I’m lucky; my wife’s soundtrack is usually “when will they re-issue onto blu-ray the Beatles Anthology tv documentary?” And I have to say, that’s a good question!

    • PaulI says:

      Ha ha! That’s gold!

    • bleorg says:

      My wife doesn’t say anything about my purchases at all because I don’t have a wife; and I buy whatever I want.

      Listenening to the 2019 mix right now!

  62. Woodsey Niles says:

    Somewhat distressing to see Amazon USA listing the Super Deluxe Edition for $69.23 today when I pre-ordered it back on August 15 and am being charged $89.80. Hopefully they will make an adjustment.

  63. Marc says:

    Uh, that was a fast cut when we came to the page with the nude picture of John and Yoko :-)
    And I agree: it is a little bit sad. Never get it why this for people break up with so much anger – because they owe each other so much.
    And yes, not that much outtakes in this box set. I have a lot of bootlegs from the beatles – but the “Abbey Road” is the album where there are nearly no bootleg outtakes available.
    But at lest for the “let it be” album there are very much outtakes available. I have a 83 CDs Box Set with all the “let it be” sessions and a 4 dvds box set with movie material. So a possible “let it be” anniversary box will be huge I guess.
    Thanks for the unboxing Paul. Always great (and expensive) to visit your page!

  64. Steve Woodhouse says:

    There’s a format you’ve missed.

    Discs 1, 2 and 3 are all now streaming from Amazon in ‘Ultra HD’ (hi-res).

    For free. Well, there’s the subscription fee.

    • Paul Sinclair says:

      Not a ‘format’ in my mind

      • Steve Woodhouse says:

        Yes, but I think it’s important to note that you can now stream pretty much everything at CD quality, and lots of titles at BETTER than CD quality.

        Whatever you or I think of the draw of the physical format, this is a potential game-changer.

        Neil Young:

        “Earth will be changed forever when Amazon introduces high quality streaming to the masses. This will be the biggest thing to happen in music since the introduction of digital audio 40 years ago.”

        Love it or hate it, it cannot be ignored.

        • Paul Sinclair says:

          You’re wrong at the end. SDE, as things stand, does not have a remit to inform about streaming on hi-res downloads. So it is being ignored.

          • Steve Woodhouse says:

            Point taken.

            But I’m not sure it’ll work. The music business ignored downloads initially, and look where it got them.

            I love SDEs. But this is £80+, and I can stream it for an extra £5 a month or so on my Amazon account. The Bowie boxes are up there in Ultra HD. Loving the Alien is £135 at Amazon.

            People still buying physical product instead of streaming appear to be doing it for two reasons (a nostalgic notion of holding the physical and quality), one of which has just disappeared.

        • Andreas says:

          Why do you think that you always have to swim with the masses? I have many hiresolution downloads on my CocktailAudio.

          BUT I can tell you that there is nothing like putting down the needle on a physical LP on a cozy autumn evening, taking a glass of wine, looking at the jacket, holding the book in my hands, seeing all those big and nice pictures and reading informative stories about every song.

          And being surrounded by all my real products gives me goosebumps, watching all the covers. You miss all that with your digital and nontouchable downloads, I can tell you.

  65. John Orr says:

    Excellent review Paul!

  66. packiging is top. Outtakes are top! New mix is otiose, loses a lot of sphere and magic, imo. Love the original mix a lot more!

  67. stevieB says:

    “Does anyone really want all 99 takes of Maxwell’s Silver Hammer?” Sad to admit it, but yes, I do.

  68. Ady Hart says:

    Got mine a couple of hours ago from HMV.
    Rather annoyingly, I’ve just had to take it back for an exchange as it had light (but noticeable) surface scratch marks on the book. Grrr!
    Hopefully the replacement will look pristine.

    From what I have seen of it so far, it’s a lovely product :)
    But I have to ask: why (once again) do we have different packaging from the Pepper and White Album Deluxe Editions?! (I was at least expecting it to be same as the Pepper box set, with a lenticular cover)…
    Oh well…!!

  69. stevieB says:

    Thanks Paul, informative and enjoyable as ever. Now that HMV in the UK have a functioning website for pre-orders, any chance of adding them to the purchase options widgets?

  70. Russell says:

    Nice job Paul. Looking forward to my copy from Amazon.FR arriving.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *